Motor Control Centers –Draw-out vs. Fixed Type, Vertical vs. Horizontal Bus

Introduction

Motor Control Centers (MCCs) are a crucial part of industrial electrical systems, providing centralized control for multiple electric motors. MCCs are used in manufacturing plants, power stations, water treatment facilities, and many other industrial applications where motor control is necessary.

However, not all MCCs are built the same. Choosing the right MCC configuration can impact system reliability, maintainability, safety, and cost-efficiency. The two key aspects of MCC configurations are:

Draw-out vs. Fixed Type MCCs
Vertical vs. Horizontal Bus Arrangements

Understanding these configurations will help engineers, plant managers, and technicians optimize motor control systems for safety, ease of maintenance, and long-term operational efficiency.

1. Draw-out vs. Fixed Type MCCs

The main distinction between MCC types is whether the motor starter units (buckets) are fixed in place or draw-out, meaning they can be easily removed for maintenance or replacement.

1.1 Fixed Type MCCs

Fixed type MCCs have permanently mounted motor starter units. All components, including circuit breakers, contactors, and overload relays, are directly wired and bolted to the MCC structure.

Advantages of Fixed Type MCCs

✔ Lower Cost – Fixed MCCs are generally less expensive to manufacture and install.
✔ Smaller Footprint – Takes up less space compared to draw-out units.
✔ Simpler Design – Fewer mechanical parts mean lower chances of failure in the MCC structure itself.
✔ Lower Maintenance Requirements – No moving parts mean fewer issues related to mechanical wear.

Disadvantages of Fixed Type MCCs

❌ Longer Downtime – If a component fails, the entire section may need to be powered down for repairs.
❌ Harder Maintenance – Electricians must disconnect wiring manually, increasing risk and time needed for servicing.
❌ Less Flexibility – Replacing or upgrading motor starters is more complex and time-consuming.

Best Use Cases for Fixed Type MCCs

Applications with minimal motor maintenance requirements.
Small industrial plants where cost is a primary concern.
Facilities with redundant systems that can afford longer downtime.

1.2 Draw-out Type MCCs

Draw-out MCCs (also called plug-in or removable MCCs) feature motor starter buckets that can be removed from the structure without disconnecting the main power to the entire MCC.

Advantages of Draw-out MCCs

✔ Quick Maintenance – The motor starter bucket can be removed and serviced without shutting down the entire MCC.
✔ Enhanced Safety – Technicians can work on motor starters in a separate area, reducing exposure to live equipment.
✔ Easier Upgrades – Allows quick changes in motor control configurations without rewiring.
✔ Minimized Downtime – Units can be swapped out rapidly, making them ideal for critical applications.

Disadvantages of Draw-out MCCs

❌ Higher Cost – More expensive than fixed MCCs due to additional mechanical and electrical complexity.
❌ Requires More Space – Draw-out MCCs tend to be larger in size due to the required clearance for removable units.
❌ Higher Maintenance – Moving parts may require periodic servicing to ensure proper alignment and operation.

Best Use Cases for Draw-out MCCs

Large industrial plants where rapid maintenance and minimal downtime are essential.
Oil & Gas, Power Plants, Pharmaceutical, and Food Processing industries where process continuity is critical.
MCCs handling multiple critical motors that need to be serviced quickly.

2. Vertical vs. Horizontal Bus Configurations

MCCs are also classified based on the arrangement of their main busbars, which distribute power to individual motor starter buckets.

2.1 Vertical Bus MCCs

In vertical bus MCCs, power is distributed using a vertical bus that runs from top to bottom inside the MCC structure. Each motor starter unit is connected to this vertical bus, making it easier to distribute power efficiently to multiple units.

Advantages of Vertical Bus MCCs

✔ Compact Design – Requires less space, making it suitable for tight electrical rooms.
✔ Easier Expansion – Additional motor starter units can be installed without major structural modifications.
✔ More Commonly Used – The preferred design for modular MCCs, especially in process industries.

Disadvantages of Vertical Bus MCCs

❌ More Vulnerable to Faults – A single-phase fault can affect all units connected to the same vertical bus.
❌ Potential Arc Flash Risks – Maintenance near a live vertical bus can pose a higher risk.

Best Use Cases for Vertical Bus MCCs

Process industries (chemical, pharmaceutical, food processing) where motor loads are frequently added or modified.
Facilities with limited space where compact MCC designs are necessary.

2.2 Horizontal Bus MCCs

Horizontal bus MCCs use a horizontally aligned busbar to distribute power across multiple sections of the MCC. The motor starter units are connected via feeder breakers or horizontal tap-off points.

Advantages of Horizontal Bus MCCs

✔ Higher Fault Tolerance – Provides better fault isolation, reducing the impact of a single-phase failure.
✔ More Robust for High Power Loads – Ideal for MCCs controlling large motors (above 100 HP).
✔ Improved Arc Flash Safety – Horizontal bus designs can incorporate better segregation and insulation for personnel safety.

Disadvantages of Horizontal Bus MCCs

❌ Takes Up More Space – Requires a wider MCC structure.
❌ More Complex Installation – Requires more wiring and breaker configurations.

Best Use Cases for Horizontal Bus MCCs

Heavy industrial applications with large motor loads, such as steel mills, oil refineries, and mining operations.
Facilities requiring higher fault protection and redundancy in power distribution.

Comparison Table: Draw-out vs. Fixed MCCs, Vertical vs. Horizontal Bus

Feature	Draw-out MCC	Fixed MCC	Vertical Bus	Horizontal Bus
Initial Cost	High	Low	Low	High
Maintenance Time	Quick	Long	Moderate	Quick
Space Requirement	More	Less	Less	More
Ease of Upgrades	Easy	Difficult	Easy	Moderate
Reliability	High	Moderate	Moderate	High
Fault Protection	High	Moderate	Moderate	High
Best For	Large, critical industrial plants	Small to medium facilities	Process industries, compact setups	Heavy industry, high-load motors

How to Choose the Right MCC Configuration

When selecting an MCC configuration, consider the following factors:

Maintenance Strategy – If rapid replacement is necessary, draw-out MCCs are the best choice.
Space Availability – Vertical bus MCCs save space, but horizontal bus MCCs offer better fault tolerance.
Budget Constraints – Fixed MCCs are more cost-effective, while draw-out MCCs provide long-term savings through reduced downtime.
Safety Requirements – Arc flash safety may be a deciding factor in choosing horizontal bus MCCs.
Industry-Specific Needs – Oil & Gas, Power Generation, and Heavy Industries often favor draw-out MCCs for reliability.

Conclusion

Motor Control Centers (MCCs) play a vital role in industrial automation and motor control. The choice between draw-out vs. fixed type MCCs and vertical vs. horizontal bus configurations directly impacts a facility’s safety, maintenance efficiency, and cost-effectiveness.

Fixed MCCs are budget-friendly but require longer downtime for repairs.
Draw-out MCCs minimize downtime and improve maintainability.
Vertical bus MCCs are compact and ideal for process industries.
Horizontal bus MCCs offer superior fault tolerance and safety.

By carefully analyzing your industrial motor control needs, you can select the best MCC configuration to ensure long-term reliability, safety, and efficiency.

Looking for More?

If you’re designing or upgrading your MCCs, consult with electrical engineers and MCC manufacturers to ensure compliance with IEC, NEMA, and IEEE standards. Let me know in the comments if you have any questions or real-world experiences with MCCs! 🚀

Share The Post :